I replaced all 4 tires withe Michelin Pilot All Season 3+ at Costco back in August 2017; they cost $210 each. ~20k miles later got an irreparable puncture in one of them. Costco doesn't carry the A/S 3+ anymore, so I got two A/S 4; they cost $200 each. So far I'm happy with bothe A/S 3+ and the A/S 4, and I'm happy with Costco's safety checks, proper torquing, and overall service.
The A/S 3+ wore out a little faster than I would've liked (they're guaranteed up to 55k miles I think, I got 20k miles up until the puncture). We'll see how the A/S 4 holds up